REVIEW
Lucien’s essay depicts a personal connection with his community service activity and provides the
why to an extracurricular that probably shows up as only one line on the
activities portion of his
college application. He starts off with an endearing anecdote of meeting his first friend in Canada and
connects the encounter to his current passion, then delves even deeper by concluding with self-
reflection and a bigger goal for society that he hopes to achieve. His personal statement gives the
reader a glimpse at his background and assimilation into a new culture, and how his own experience
as an immigrant motivates him to help other immigrants adapt to life in a new place.
The strengths of this essay lie in the vivid and charming recounting
of his first encounter with
Jack, his first friend in a foreign new environment, and how he uses that story to explain his passion
for volunteering. He connects his community service to a bigger goal at the end of the essay that
leaves the reader feeling inspired, and alludes to his thoughts, hopes, and dreams. There is a tone of
humility and humor as he depicts how he met his first friend by bumping
his head under the table, and
makes a motif out of the head bump by referring to it again later when he’s talking about helping
other immigrant children. He modestly credits his noble deeds at the community service agency to
meeting his first friend, and humbly reveals his hope that his own good deeds will inspire others to
pay it forward. He does a good job of exhibiting his accomplishments in community service without
sounding like he’s bragging.
Lucien could also make the essay more memorable and distinctive by including anecdotes of his
experiences at the community service agency where he gave seminars and organized field trips. He
denotes his volunteering
responsibilities in list form, which can seem a bit impersonal and résumé-
like. For example, he mentions how he tried to understand the people he helped, but does not include
how he goes about doing this, or whether learning about those unique individuals contributed to his
experience. Adding a story of how he changed the lives of the immigrants he helped would enhance
his message and create a fitting parallel with the anecdote of how Jack
helped him as he assimilated
into Western culture.
Overall, Lucien combines humor with humility and leaves the reader feeling inspired.
—C. C. Gong