Choice C is the best answer. In the second paragraph of Passage 1,
Douglas uses a rhetorical question to stress that the division into slave
and free states has existed since the beginning of the United States:
“I now come back to the question, why cannot this Union exist forever,
divided into Free and Slave States, as our fathers made it?” It can
be inferred from this question that Douglas believes that since this
division is long-standing, the provisions for it in the US Constitution
have provided a good basic structure that doesn’t need to be changed.
Choice A is incorrect because in Passage 1, Douglas doesn’t observe
that the US Constitution’s provisions for slavery lack a means for
reconciling differences between slave states and free states. Choice B
is incorrect because although Douglas stresses that the provisions
for slavery are long-standing, he doesn’t characterize them as having
somehow anticipated the Union’s expansion to the west. Choice D
is correct because although it can be inferred from Passage 1 that
Douglas believes the provisions for slavery have had a positive
economic impact, he nowhere implies that the founders based them on
an assumption that slavery was economically necessary.
QUESTION 34
Choice B is the best answer. The previous question asks about how
Douglas, in Passage 1, characterizes the Constitution’s provisions for
slavery. The answer, that Douglas believes they provided a good basic
structure and don’t need to be changed, is best supported in the first
sentence of the second paragraph of Passage 1: “I now come back to
the question, why cannot this Union exist forever, divided into Free
and Slave States, as our fathers made it?”
Choices A, C, and D are incorrect because the cited lines don’t support
the answer to the previous question. Instead, they describe the various
ways in which the nation has expanded since its founding (choice A),
stress the likelihood that the nation will only continue to expand
(choice C), and assert the importance of the sovereignty of individual
states to the future expansion of the nation (choice D).
ANSwER ExPlANATIONS
| SAT Practice Test #8 QUESTION 35