bands are my treasures, as they hold my past experiences while
stretching to encompass the
performances held in my future.
REVIEW
Sara adopts a unique and innovative approach to her essay; instead of speaking directly about her
love
of theater, she presents this passion through the framework of her headband collection. This
narrative structure gives her an avenue to exhibit the multifaceted nature of her personality, which she
describes to be as varied as her array of headbands.
Throughout her essay, Sara reveals herself to be capable of highly evocative imagery that
successfully skirts oversentimentality. There are a few aspects of
her essay that can be improved,
however. First, her headbands are given a large amount of credit in the first two paragraphs—it is too
much to say that “the story of [her] life is unearthed every morning” when she puts on her headgear.
Additionally, much of the language in the essay is overwritten. Using more subdued language to
express the significance of her headbands would convey the same message while maintaining
credibility. Her word choice is excessive—her use of words like “multitudinous,” “minute,”
“donned,” “unremitting,” and “amalgamation” is at best unnecessary and at worst misleading.
With all of that said the last paragraph of the essay is quite commendable: The line on the $1
monetary value of her headbands is very memorable and, the final sentence ties all parts of the essay
together, providing a highly effective conclusion for what is ultimately a deeply personal and
revealing essay.
—Melody Y. Guan