REVIEW
It definitely takes guts to start a college essay by talking about your bladder. In the case of Leslie’s
essay, this risky move paid off: Personal statements without any foibles or humility read as
unrealistic, unappealing ego boosts. Leslie’s essay, on the other hand, most certainly does not portray
its author as perfect, and by reveling in his own flaws instead of
refusing to acknowledge them, the
author evinces a charmingly self-effacing sense of humor, as well as a willingness to tackle
challenges. Anyone who has ever delivered a speech with a quavering voice and a cold sweat running
down their brow can easily relate to his detailed descriptions of his nervousness. Leslie does not try
to cast himself as fearless, but rather as able to go on despite his fear—as a result,
his essay has a
sense of humor and believability.
But though he tells an interesting story, it leaves some questions unanswered. What is Leslie
speaking about? Is the topic itself important, or is the experience his focus? Though he closes by
explaining that overcoming this fear is his goal, the essay begs for answers to these questions and
would be improved if he were able to deliver them.
Despite this blip, Leslie succeeds in crafting a winning personal statement
that projects likability,
determination, and ambition to overcome challenges to succeed, all without making Leslie come off
as egotistical or cocky. His humorous and engaging essay serves its purpose well.
—Erica X. Eisen