Remediation of Pb/Cd-Contaminated Forest Soils by Compost and Mycorrhizae: will it be a solution to the Forest Dieback?



Yüklə 58.12 Kb.
PDF просмотр
tarix21.08.2017
ölçüsü58.12 Kb.

Remediation of Pb/Cd-Contaminated Forest Soils by Compost and 

Mycorrhizae: will it be a solution to the Forest Dieback? 

Gunadasa HKSG 

1

+

, Yapa PI 



2

, Nissanka SP 

3

 and Perera SP 



4

  

1



 Postgraduate Institute of Agriculture, University of Peradeniya, Sri Lanka 

2

Faculty of Agricultural Sciences, Sabaragamuwa University of Sri Lanka, Sri Lanka. 



3

Faculty of Agriculture, University of Peradeniya, Sri Lanka. 

4

Rubber Research Institute, Agalawatta, Sri Lanka 



Abstract.

 Horton Plains is an upper montane forest in Sri Lanka that acts as the most important water 

catchment of the island. Soil pollution and forest dieback (FDB) have become the major threat for this 

sensitive natural ecosystem. Increasing vehicle emissions in the nearby cities and the rain polluted with Pb 

and Cd falling on forest soils has been the key focus of the study. In the experiment, twenty-four permanent 

plots were established within an area of 61-80% dieback severity and three soil amendments through addition 

of (a) compost, (b) montane mycorrhizae, and (c) compost and montane mycorrhizae, alongside the control 

made up the four treatments used in this study. Treatments were applied to five randomly selected Sysygium 



rotundifolium saplings of approximate height of 1m and 0.015m diameter breast height (DBH) residing in 

each plot.  Soil organic matter content (SOM) and Pb and Cd were compared from soil samples collected at 

0.2m depth. These comparisons were done for samples collected at three different stages and during the 

experimental period, the selected saplings were closely monitored and changes in health were accordingly 

recorded. The soil analysis shows clear indications of Pb and Cd contamination which impairs plant 

metabolism leading to dieback. Effect of standard compost and montane mycorrhizae on protecting saplings 

from Pb and Cd was significant (= <0.001). Moreover, compost and mycorrhizae appeared to be effective 

in reducing the effect of Pb and Cd on sapling’s mortality. Significant decline of Cd (p = 0.01) and Pb (p = 

0.01) with the increasing SOM level were observed. 

Keywords:

 Forest dieback, Compost,  heavy metals. 



1.  Introduction  

The Upper Montane Forest in Horton Plains, Sri Lanka, as it was in 1947, was described as a low, dense, 

slow-growing forest with a healthy and vigorous appearance [1]. It is located on the highest plateau of Sri 

Lanka, which lies between 1,500 and 2,524m average sea level [2] and the geographical location is in the 

Central Highlands of the Central Province, 6’47 – 6’50’N, 80’ 46’- 80’50’E.  Annual rainfall in the region is 

about 2540 mm. Temperatures are low, with an annual mean of 13°C, and ground frost is common in 

February [3]. The landscape characteristically consists of gently undulating highland plateau at the southern 

end of the central mountain massif of Sri Lanka. Soil order Ultisol is characterized by a thick, black, organic 

layer at the surface. Horton Plains is the most important catchments area of the countryand tributaries of 

three major rivers originate from within the reserve. The land area covered by this montane rain forest is 

approximately 3,160 ha. There are 54 woody species, of which 27 (50%) are endemic to Sri Lanka. 

Belonging to different size and age classes of these forest, have been dying due to a yet unknown factor. This 

phenomenon was first observed in the Horton Plains National Park and the earliest reports of a significant 

level of dieback in the forest were by [4]. Estimations using recent satellite images combined with ground 

surveys revealed that about 654 ha, equivalent to 24.5% of the forest in the park has been subjected to 

                                                           

+

 Gunadasa HKSG  Tel.: +94 071-8196520  



  Email address: sajanee2010@gmail.com 

2012 International Conference on Future Environment and Energy

IPCBEE vol.28(2012) © (2012)IACSIT Press, Singapoore

139


dieback  [5]. One of the worst affected trees was Syzygium rotundifolium followed by Cinnamomum 

ovalifoliumNeolitsea fuscataSyzygium revolutum and Calophyllum walkeri.  Also, seedling establishment 

and forest regeneration in the area is slow [5]. Healthy forest in the park amounts to about 2012 ha. The 

extent of the damage to the forest from dieback appears to be so severe that the stand structure in affected 

areas show dramatic changes. If this dieback continues with the current rate, the majority of the large trees 

will disappear from the forest soon. The vital functions offered by this precious forest will then be subjected 

to significant changes most probably towards the negative side. Work done by many researchers so far has 

ended up with no significant clues about the causal agents and remedial measures for the dieback though 

work done by [6]. has indicated the contamination of soils in the Horton plains by Pb and Cd and possible 

links of the soil pollution to forest dieback. Therefore, the main objective of the study is to check the ability 

of SOM in effectively remediating Pb and Cd in the affected soils.   



2.  Materials and Methods 

Twenty-four permanent experimental plots of 20 m 

× 20 m were demarcated using GPS (Global 

Positioning System) points with a 20 cm accuracy to represent an affected area in the Horton Plain National 

Park. Randomized Complete Block Design (RCBD) was used with six blocks to replicate each and every 

treatment six times. Plot locations were selected to cover a 61 – 80 % dieback of trees and to maintain soil 

and topography as constant as possible. Four soil amendments (a).compost-2kg/sapling, (b). compost and 

montane mycorrhizae-4kg/sapling. (c).montane mycorrhizae-2kg/sapling including a control were used for 

the study while taking Syzygium rotundifolium as the indicator plant. An Investigation of harmful elements 

such as Pb and Cd in the soil samples were measured by wet ash method [7] and the extractants were 

analyzed for the above elements by Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometry [8]. In addition, the soil organic 

matter content was determined using the method of total organic C by Walkley and Black described by [9]. 

The soil samples were collected from 0.20m depth and 0.3m-0.5m away from each sapling representing three 

different time periods. Furthermore, Death rates of the saplings were calculated by keeping records of the 

selected saplings throughout the experimental period and counting the deaths at the end of the trial.   

3.  Results and Discussion 

The results shown in this paper are based on the work done during the two-year study period within the 

61-80% dieback areas selected in the Horton Plains National Park (HPNP), Sri Lanka. Soil organic matter 

content and heavy metals such as Pb and Cd were compared first among treatments under three stages of 

sampling. In addition, the data collected were compared with the death rate of the saplings. 

3.1. 

Soil organic matter 

Soil organic matter (SOM) level in the study area of Horton Plains has not reached upper levels in the 

range, up to 12%, as expected in tropical moist evergreen forests [10]. In ordinary tropical moist evergreen 

forests, SOM content varies around 6%  [10]. Relatively low plant nutrient levels in montane forests are not 

unusual according to past studies (e.g., ([11].). For each 1000m rise in altitude, there is a 7

o

C drop in 



temperature [12]. This has a dramatic effect on plant and animal distribution in this ecosystem. With the 

elevation of about 2524m, Horton Plains is cold (mean annual temperature 15 

°

C) and contains a very 



specific vegetation which is much more sensitive to the changes in the environment than normal tropical 

forests [13]. Under the prevailing conditions in the montane environment –low sunlight, low temperature, 

shallow soil depth and so on, production of SOM is weaker in the Horton Plains than in an ordinary tropical 

forest [14]. As far as the SOM content is concerned, there are significant differences among the treatments at 

soil sampling stage 1 (p = <.001), stage 2 (p = <.001), and stage 3 (<.001) in the 0.2m depth (Fig 1(a) ). The 

soils treated with compost and compost + mycorrhizae mixture showed the higher values of soil organic 

matter though soils treated with mycorrhizae only and the control showed the lowest at all three stages. 

Fluctuation of SOM levels in the area may be linked with temperature, rainfall, soil depth and addition of 

organic debris from the aggressively growing undercover vegetation such as Strobilanthus  spp.     The 

function of SOM springs from its effects on soil structural stability (its action as a bonding agent between 

primary and secondary mineral particles leads to enhanced amount, size and stability of aggregates) and soil 

water retention (as a water adsorbing agent, it enhances water acceptance and availability) and, hence, on 

140


infiltration and percolation. At the same time, SOM controls soil nutrients that affect biomass. [15] 

emphasized that soil structural stability is influenced by the type of organic matter, as well as its amount. 

Therefore, in some cases, high SOM content is not accompanied by high structural stability. [16] pointed out 

that some fungi exude oxalic acid, which enhances dispersion and breakdown of aggregates. Humic 

substances are the components of SOM which play the key role in detoxifying the soil from pollutants such 

as Pb and Cd residues of Agro-chemicals from surrounding areas [15].  Unsatisfactory levels of SOM exhibit 

the poor activity of humic substances and resultant soil pollution. It should also be noted that even a milder 

form of soil contamination in the Horton Plains cannot be afforded since the montane vegetation is highly 

sensitive to the changes in the environment.  

3.2. 

 Heavy Metals in soil (Pb and Cd) 

The level of soil Pb and Cd has gone up to 106 and 7.29 ppm respectively. The maximum allowable limit 

of Pb is 100 ppm while it is 3ppm for Cd [17]. Even the smallest amount of both Pb and Cd may impose 

severe damages on plant’s metabolism leading to dieback [18].  Results from soil analysis clearly indicated 

contamination of soil from these two trace elements in Horton Plains. Treatments used for the study have 

significantly influenced the soil Pb at sampling stages 1 (p=0.01) and 2 (p=0.004) but there is no significant 

influence detected at stage-3 (p=0.79) (Fig 2(a)) and the highest Pb content was observed in the control. 

Cadmium content in the soils of the study area is not significantly different with the treatments at stage-1 

(p=0.18), -2 (p=0.35), and -3 (p=0.51) though the highest is observed in the control (Fig 2(b)). Mycorrhizae 

significantly increase the absorption of various elements from the soil including heavy metals such as Pb and 

Cd  [18]. Therefore, it could be assumed that mycorrhizae are responsible for the reduction of Pb and Cd in 

the soil treated with mycorrhizae. Soil microorganisms play a vital role in maintaining overall soil quality. 

They have been proved to be effective in detoxifying pollutants in the soil that include heavy metals such as 

Pb and Cd. Soil microbes (e.g, mycorrhizae)  on the other hand, maintain extremely useful symbiotic 

associations with the forest vegetations which provide additional advantage for the plants to mine nutrients 

and water [19].  



3.3. 

Death rate of Syzygium rotundifolium saplings 

It was clearly evident that the addition of standard compost and mycorrhizae has significantly controlled 

the death of Syzygium rotundifolium saplings. Treatment effect on the death of saplings is significant (p=

0.001) whilst the control clearly shows the highest death rate (Fig 1(b)). The standard compost consists of 

humic and fulvic acids that are formed during the microbial decomposition of organic materials. These 

specific molecules, known as humic substances, possess extraordinary capability of immobilizing soil 

contaminants such as Pb and Cd. Additionally, dozens of fractions in compost help the plants to withstand 

stressful conditions such as drought, nutrient imbalances, acidity and so on [20].  In addition, standard 

compost is a good reservoir of all forms of essential plant nutrients and growth factors of plants [20]. 

Mycorrhizae, on the other hand, act as a remarkable symbiotic mechanism for the plants to survive under 

stressful conditions such as droughts, nutrient deficiency, soil contaminants such as Pb and Cd [18]. Thus, it 

could be argued that treating the Syzygium rotundifolium samplings with standard compost and mycorrhizae 

until they become grownup trees might help to fill the gaps caused by the dieback in the forest.   

3.4.  Soil organic matter Vs Pb in the soil 

The content of soil Pb is inversely proportional to the SOM content (Fig 3(a)) and the relationship was 

statistically significant( p = <0.001). The findings indicate that the availability of Pb in the soil for plants in 

the study area could be reduced by increasing SOM level. The nature of the decline of Pb with the increasing 

SOM level seems to be linear-by-linear type. Immobilization of soluble Pb in the soil by the humic and 

fulvic acid molecules present in SOM has been documented by several researchers (e.g., [18]).  

141


    

 

Fig. 1: (a) Status of SOM% among the treatments; (b) Death rate of the saplings after 2 years with  four different  



treatments   

3.5. Soil organic matter Vs Cd in the soil 

The relationship between the availability of Cd in the soil and SOM content was significant at p = 0.01. 

The nature of the relationship was a linear-by-linear as shown in fig. 3(b). According to the graph soil Cd 

levels gradually decreased with the increasing SOM level. The results clearly show that the effect of 

available soil Cd on montane vegetation could be reduced by improving SOM level. Action of humic and 

fulvic acid on immobilization of Cd may have resulted these relationships [18]. The results in general 

indicate that the maintenance of SOM will help to mitigate Cd toxicity on forest vegetation.   

        

 

 Fig.2:  (a) Status of Pb among  treatments at four different stages of sampling; (b) Status of Cd among  treatments at 



four different stages of sampling  

         

SOM %

40

3



5

7

25



9

30

11



35

4

8



10

6

55



50

45

P



 b

 (



m

)



     

SOM %


3

5

7



2

9

3



4

5

6



7

4

8



6

10

C



 d

 (



m

)



     

SOM %


6

40

7



50

5

60



70

80

20



8

30

4



D

 e

 a



 t

 h

  r



 a

 t

 e



 %

 

  Fig.3: (a) Soil organic matter Vs Pb in soil; (b) Soil organic matter Vs Cd in soil; Soil organic matter content in the 



soil Vs Death rate of saplings        

3.6.  Soil organic matter content in the soil and dieback of plants 

Results show that the increase of SOM level helps to reduce the death of saplings. The relationship 

between SOM level and the death rate of the saplings (Sysigium rotudifolium) was significant (p = 0.05). The 

nature of the relationship seems to be linear-by-linear and it further indicates that by maintaining SOM level 

somewhere above 4%, the death rate of the saplings could significantly be reduced (see fig 3(c)). Humic and 

fulvic acid molecules in SOM effectively immobilize toxic metals such as Pb and Cd in the soil [16].  



4.  Conclusions 

Y =3+ 2 / (1+X) 

R2 = 91.7% 

P = <0.001 

Y= 7.6-2.3/ (1-

0.05X) 


P= 0.01 

R

2



= 29%

Y = 20.3 – 1.8 / (1-0.3X) 



P = 0.05 

R

2



= 62% 

142


Soil pollution in the montane forest with Pb and Cd as affected by increasing vehicle emissions and 

consequential    polluted rain appears to be one of the key causes for the deterioration of the vegetation by 

forest dieback. Extra sensitivity of the montane forest vegetation to the changes in the soil may have 

triggered the impact of soil pollution.  Enrichment of the polluted forest soil with standard compost and 

montane mycorrhizae appears to be effective in saving  the saplings of Syzygium rotundifolium (one of the 

worst affected trees) from untimely death. Maintenance of SOM at satisfactory levels in the soil appears to 

be effective in reducing the levels of both Pb and Cd in the soil.  

5.  Acknowledgements 

This study was conducted with the financial support of Sabaragamuwa University of Sri Lanka and the 

Department of Wildlife Conservation.  

6.  References 

[1]  T.W. Hoffmann. The Horton Plains, Good and Bad news. Loris. 1988. 18 (1): 4-5. 

[2]  Whitmore TC, (1984). Tropical Rain Forests of the Far East. Claredon Press, Oxford. 

[3]  Wijewansa  RA, (1983). Horton Plains: a plea for preservation. Loris. 16: 188-191. 

[4]  W.L. Werner.The Upper Montane forests of Sri Lanka. The Sri Lanka Forester.1982. 15: 119-135. 

[5]  N.K.B. Adikaram, K.B. Ranawana, A .Weerasuriya. Forest dieback in the Horton Plains National Park.  Sri Lanka 



Protected Areas Management and Wildlife Conservation Project. Department of Wild Life Conservation, Ministry 

of Environment and Natural Resourses, Colombo: 08. 2006. 

[6]  H.K.S.G. Gunadasa, P.I. Yapa, S.P. Nissanka, S.P. Peter, Forest dieback as affected by soil pollution with Pb and 

Cd: an example from Sri Lanka, International conference on environmental science and Development – ICESD 

2012. 5-7, January 2012. 2012. (accepted).  

[7]  USEPA. Method 3050B. acid digestion of sediments, sludges and soils. Revision 2; 1996. 

[8]  E. Dale, and H. Norman.  Atomic absorption and flame emission spectrometry. In: Page AL, Miller RH, Keeney 

DR, Editors. Methods of Soil Analysis, Part 2, 2nd ed, Agronomy 9,Madison, WI, USA: American Society of 

Agronomy Inc; 1982, p. 13-27. 

[9]  D.W. Nelson, L.E. Sommers. Total carbon , organic carbon and organic matter. In method of soil analysis. Part 2. 

2

nd

 Ed. Agronomy No. 09, American Society of Agronomy, Madison, WI,USA. 1982. 



[10]  P.L. Weaver, E. Medina, D. Pool, K. Dugger, J. Gonzales, E. Cuevas. Ecological observations in the   dwarf cloud 

forest of the Luquillo Mountains in Puerto Rico.  Biotropica.  1986.10: 278-291. 

[11]  D. Mueller-Dombois, P.M. Vitousek, K.W. Bridges.(1984). Canopy dieback and ecosystem processes in Pacific 

forests: a progress report and research proposal. Hawaii Bot Sci.1984. 44: 100.  

[12]  A. Kaplan, M.A. Cane, Y. Kushnir, A.C. Clement, M.B. Blumenthal, B. Rajagopalan.  Analyses of global sea 

surface temperature 1856-1991. J Geophys Res-Oceans, 1998. 103(C9): 18567-18589. 

[13]  Lloyd, L. Loope, T.W. Giambelluca. Vulnerability of Island Tropical Montane Cloud Forests to Climate Change

with Special Reference to East Maui, Hawaii. Climatic Change.1998 39 : 503-517.  

[14]  P.J. Edwards, and P.J. Grubb. (). Studies of mineral cycling in a montane rain forest in New Guinea. I. The 

distribution of organic matter in the vegetation and soil. J  Ecol. 197765: 943-969. 

[15]  P. Dutartre, F. Bartoli, F. Andreux, J.M. Portal, A. Ange. Influence of content and nature of organic matter on the 

structure of some sandy soils from West Africa. Geoderma. 1993. 56: 459-478.   

[16]  R.P. Voroney, J.A. Van Veen, E.A. Paul. Organic carbon dynamics in grassland soils. II. Model validation and 

simulation of the long-term effects of cultivation and rainfall erosion. Can J  Soil Sci.1981.61: 211-224. 

[17]  A. Kloke. Orientierungsdaten für tolerierbare gesamtgehalte einiger elemente in kulturboden mitt. VDLUFA. 1980. 

H.1-3: 9-11. 

[18]  A.B. Pahlsson . Toxicity of heavy metals (Zn, Cu, Cd, Pb) to Vascular Plants. Water Air  Soil Poll.1989. 47: 287-

319. 

143


[19]  M.J. Harrison. The arbuscular mycorrhizal symbiosis: An underground association. Trends in Plant Sci. 1997. 2

54–59. 


[20]  I. Weissenhorn  , C. Leyval, J. Berthelin, Bioavailability of heavy metals and abundance of arbuscular mycorrhizal 

in a soil polluted by atmospheric deposition from a smelter. Biol  Fert  Soils.1995.19: 22-28. 



144


Verilənlər bazası müəlliflik hüququ ilə müdafiə olunur ©azkurs.org 2016
rəhbərliyinə müraciət

    Ana səhifə