repay my parents for all of their sacrifices, the least I could do was to help find them a home that they
could call their own—and that year, I did. To me, a home means more than the general conception of
“four walls and a roof.” A home is a place filled with memories and laughter from my family. No
matter
where my future may lead me, I know that if at times I feel alone, I will always have a yellow
home with my family inside waiting for me.
REVIEW
Eda’s essay captures the reader ’s interest immediately with the startling title, “Homeless for Thirteen
Years.” It intentionally sets misleading expectations; she is not homeless in the traditional sense of
lacking a roof over her head, but in the sense of not having a true house to call home.
Her readers
become emotionally invested in the story, worried for the fate of the girl weeping and desperately
praying on her parents’ bed. Eda soon reveals that though her family has suffered hardships, she has
not spent her life living on the streets. This disparity draws attention to her point that a home is more
than “‘four walls and a roof,’” but at the cost of potentially downplaying the situations of those who
are traditionally “homeless.” The technique
serves her well enough, but beware of rhetorical devices
that may be unintentionally misconstrued.
Additionally, Eda’s essay at times delves into cliché. It would be improved with more nuance about
her definition of a home, lest it begin to sound like a dictionary entry. Avoiding phrases like “No
matter where my future may lead me” or “not going to allow this obstacle to hinder” would further
strengthen the prose.
However, Eda’s essay consistently engages her readers. Her theme is compelling by its own right;
the idea that home should be “a place filled with memories and laughter” is easily appreciated. But she
doesn’t present this theme as an abstract ideal. Rather, she concretely describes her desires to host
sleepovers and
to have a room to gossip about, and her longing to have a familiar place where her
family will always be waiting inside. Eda’s essay grabs its readers and keeps them emotionally
invested. It makes them care.
—Indrani G. Das