Research methodology
31
Intervention studies
In
intervention studies, the researcher manipulates a situation and measures the effects of
this manipulation. Usually (but not always) two groups are compared, one group in which the
intervention takes place (e.g. treatment with a certain drug) and
another group that remains
‘untouched’ (e.g. treatment with a placebo).
The two categories of intervention studies are:
•
experimental studies and
•
quasi-experimental studies
1. Experimental studies
An experimental design is a study design
that gives the most reliable proof for causation. In
an
experimental study, individuals are randomly allocated to at least two groups. One group
is subject to an intervention,
or experiment, while the other group(s) is not. The outcome of
the intervention (effect of the intervention on the dependent variable/problem) is obtained by
comparing the two groups. A number of experimental study designs have been developed.
These are widely used in laboratory settings and in clinical settings. For ethical reasons, the
opportunities for experiments involving human subjects are restricted. However,
randomised
control trials of new drugs are common.
At community level, where health research is frequently undertaken, we experience not only
ethical but also practical problems in carrying out experimental studies.
In real life settings, it
is often impossible to assign persons at random to two groups, or to maintain a control group.
Therefore, experimental research designs may have to be replaced by quasi-experimental
designs.
Dostları ilə paylaş: