And the perennial question about tiers of identity remains:
Are these peoples
first of all Muslims, or are they ethnic/national groups of Tatars, Uzbeks,
Kakaks, Tajiks, and so forth? Or are they part of a larger pan-Turkic group? Or
citizens of Russia? The reality is that they can be any and all of these things
depending on circumstances. They are not mutually exclusive.
Which identity
will dominate at any given time depends upon circumstances.
Muslims around the world have been generally aware that the Soviet Union
itself severely persecuted Islam. At the same time, they valued the vital role of
the USSR in providing a geostrategic balance against
the colonial and imperial
forces of the West. The mere existence of the USSR and a bipolar world
provided maneuvering room for small states, preventing formerly Western
imperial states from extending total domination over them.
The subsequent
collapse of the USSR dismayed the Muslim world and most neutral nations—not
because they favored communism, but because it spelled the end of a bipolar
world and rendered small states more vulnerable to the remaining single global
superpower’s will.