41
The EJ260 scintillator has the least transmission loss at 430 nm, however at this
wavelength, absorption by its fluor dopants are ongoing.
In these scintillators,
the free radicals formed would compete with absorption of light by the fluors,
but wouldn’t further quench the final wave-shifted light which has an emission
peak at 490 nm. This feature is marketed as a contributor to the radiation hardness
of these scintillators by the manufacturer [21].
The downside of this scintillator however is that it
will not couple well to the
Y11 fibers currently used in the detector, which absorb light over the range 420
-450 nm. Thus using EJ260 as a replacement candidate would require replacing
the fibers as well. The radiation hardness of these would then have to be taken
into account and may add additional costs.
The blue scintillators perform very similarly to each other. There aren’t any major
distinctions in the performance between the PVT and
PS based scintil lators in
terms of their transparency loss at 430 nm. EJ200 appears to perform only slightly
better than the other blue scintillators for the doses ranging between ~8 MGy and
25 MGy. EJ208 however, has the least transparency loss at the highest dose of
~80 MGy. It should be noted here that the peak emission wavelength of EJ208 is
at 435 nm as compared to 425 nm for all the other blue scintillators.
Since all of the scintillators have slight variations
in their absorption regions
based on the types of fluors which they are doped with,
comparing their
transparency loss at one wavelength alone is not sufficient. Figure 5-5 therefore
shows the relative transmission for each scintillator at their respective
wavelengths of maximum light emission.
This plot further confirms that for the higher wavelength
shifting scintillators,
i.e. EJ260 and EJ208, less transmission loss occurs at their wavelengths of
maximum light emission. Therefore, their emitted light will be subjected to less
quenching via competitive absorption by free
radicals as compared to the
standard blue emitting scintillators. Furthermore, these
standard blue emitting
scintillators perform within 20% variation of each other.