REVIEW
Lisa dedicates the bulk of her essay to describing her first ballet solo and the life lessons learned
during that experience. Making a single important moment into an applicable exemplar of important
changes is a common tool for the personal statement and Lisa does it well. Her prose falls easily and
gives the reader a solid feel for what Lisa
might be like as a student and, more importantly, a person.
Losing the “person” in a personal essay is a common mistake and attempting to highlight one’s
attributes can make an essay fall flat and toneless. Lisa avoids that well here.
Lisa masterfully hits many key moments in her personal statement. Her opening blends art and
science, subtly showing her depth as a student. The first two lines are excellent as the subject of dance
immediately bumps heads with the language of science, allowing Lisa to hit one of the key purposes
of a personal statement: demonstrating diversity. She successfully and humbly shows many different
strengths using only one moment of her dance career.
The story’s short length gives her room to finish the essay with a quick laundry list of things that
she can conquer and presumably has. But this conclusion detracts significantly from her essay. Many
of those things can be checked on a résumé by an admissions counselor.
In an essay about taking
risks, she plays it safe right at the end and stumbles just a bit. Overall, this is an excellent essay that
would impress admissions officers at Harvard or any other college.
—Amy Friedman