Professional training at a working place
88
74
85
79
- local availability of specialized training
services
84
78
77
68
- extent of staff training
92
74
94
88
308
availability of skilled employees – 80,8 (35
th
).
According to the Human Development Index by the United Nations
Development Programme in 2018 Ukraine is rated 88 (“high human
development”) out of 189 countries and improved its position
comparing with 90th place in 2016 [20]. The HDI sub index “education
index” has been above average and has been constantly improving since
1990 from 0,648 up to 0,794 in 2014-2017.
As a result of above discussed we distinguish such main problems in
Ukrainian HE and indicate possible ways of their solution (Table 6.4).
Table 6.4
Key problems of the Ukrainian HE and possible solutions
Problems
Solutions
- Relatively low competitiveness
of the national education system.
- Corruption.
- Excessive hierarchy and
bureaucracy.
- Lack of universities real
autonomy.
- Low status and salaries of HEIs
staff.
- Outdated teaching and research
methods not corresponding with
the market and students‟ needs.
- Education and teaching
dominate science and research.
- The need to comply with
complicated formal (and not
necessarily logical) requirements
of the Ministry of Education and
Science for the educational
process.
- Political will for radical changes,
especially overcoming corruption.
- Full autonomy of HEIs.
- Modernization of curriculum, teaching and
research methods.
- Adopting a visionary multidisciplinary /
interdisciplinary and corporate/cross-
industrial approach to education, promoting
an education-research-industry synergy.
- Improving teachers‟ external motivation
and status.
- Improving conditions for students and
teachers to conduct research.
- Introduction of a set of measures to restore
international reputation of Ukrainian HE.
- Increasing participation of Ukrainian HEIs
and individuals in European and world
educational programs and events.
Source: developed by the authors
The mentioned problems along with the general political and socio-
economical crisis in Ukraine predetermine educational migration from
the country while growth of demand for high-quality educational
services, their vast availability abroad, and harmonization of educational
standards and reduction of transportation and communication costs
enable and stimulate [7].
Modern waves of migration from Ukraine are young, since the
decision on migrating abroad is often taken after secondary school
graduation, when a HEI is being selected for further studies.
309
In total, over 70 thousand of Ukrainians study abroad, including
around 50 thousand – in European HEIs. The most desirable countries
for Ukrainian youth are: Great Britain (43%); the United States (38%);
Germany (33%); Poland (26%); Canada (25%); France (14%); Czech
Republic (10%); Russia (5%); Spain (5%); Israel (4%); Portugal (2%);
Greece (2%); Hungary (2%) [4]. Popularity of Great Britain and the
USA can be explained by the fact that their educational systems are
most competitive and up to date, they also create best job opportunities
for the graduates and contribute most to the learning of English and
inspire considerable interest to their cultures. Poland is also popular. In
2015, according to the Statistics Department of Poland, there were 20.5
thousand Ukrainians in Polish HEIs. It should be noted that the data
includes only students who participated in the programs implying
international certificates and diplomas, not including those participating
in internships and semester training programs.
The following key reasons for educational migration from Ukraine
can be highlighted: 1) high quality of scientific and technical provision
in foreign HEIs, 2) practical training programs; 3) possibility of
internships and employment in foreign companies; 4) possibility to
improve foreign languages skills; 5) opportunity to travel more with a
student visa; 6) generally higher level of education with better work
prospective.
Main motives for educational migration can be divided into three
categories: 1) personal growth related; 2) future career factors; 3)
academic motives [11]. Personal growth motives include learning new
languages and acquiring new skills, getting acquainted with a different
country, culture, and new people. Career motives are related to
prospects
through
life
related
to
qualification
development,
communication success and appropriate remuneration. Academic
motives include access to institutions with high level of education,
research, and improving personal performance in particular fields.
Many developing countries (e.g. Philippines and India) facilitate
migration of their citizens abroad for studying. This can be explained by
the fact that they cannot independently provide adequate level of
education and are interested in improving the future economic, social
and cultural development of the population this way. Even in developed
countries, migration is not considered to be the main factor of the
economy or human capital deterioration. Young people are looking for
ways of personal development, finding new friends, cultural learning,
improving the knowledge of foreign languages – and in many countries
310
of the EU they can find educational opportunities that are free and high-
quality.
While taking the decision about migrating abroad, people assess
relative costs and benefits associated with such step. However,
educational migration is also considered as a type of self-investment.
Therefore, we can distinguish the following cases/scenarios for young
people deciding to study abroad: 1) limited possibility of studying at
home, but high returns from obtained education. After graduation
students return home; 2) unlimited opportunities for studying at home,
but low returns from obtained education. After graduation students do
not return home.
According to the policy of the European Union students can continue
working in the foreign countries after completing their studies. In Italy,
Spain and Hungary, young people can be employed after they were
educated there, and they should only find an employer and get work
permission. France and Austria allow their university graduates to stay
in the country and work for half a year after graduation. Poland and
Germany provide such an opportunity during a year and a half
respectively, but the person is obliged to work according to the obtained
specialty, and the employer must prove that a vacant post for a citizen of
this country cannot be provided. In spring 2016, the European
Parliament adopted the directive that obliges all EU member states to
allow people who have received education there to stay on their territory
for at least 9 months in order to find a job.
A number of countries including Austria, Czech Republic, France,
Germany, Greece, Italy, Norway and Slovakia provide free education
for Ukrainians. Often the certificate of knowledge of the official
language of the chosen country is obligatory.
Another resource that facilitates studying of Ukrainian students
abroad is the Erasmus+ program, which replaced its previous version
(Erasmus Mundus) in 2014 [9]. According to the Delegation of the
European Union to Ukraine data, in 2004-2014 as much as 1800
Ukrainian students and researchers took part in the program, and since
2014 – more than 1000 persons already. Ukrainian participants were
expected to pay only the visa costs, while the costs for travel, studying
and accommodation were covered by the European funds. It is expected
that the program will be implemented during 2014-2020 and will cover
the following main areas: 1) cooperation for the sake of innovation and
development; 2) academic mobility; 3) policy support in the areas of
education, training and amateur sport.
311
Unfortunately only a small number of Ukrainian students took part in
the Erasmus Mundus program comparing for example with the
neighboring Poland (42 thousand students since 1998). However, due to
better access to information and opening of borders between countries,
Dostları ilə paylaş: |