71
T
HE
I
DEA
OF
I
MPLEMENTING
THE
C
ONCEPT
OF
Y
AMAHA
M
USIC
S
CHOOL
INTO
E
LEMENTARY
S
CHOOL
The profi le of YMS alumni is completely different from the alumni of elementary
music school. Those who want to study at YMS are usually children or adults who
do not have high ambitions, those who are not attracted by classical music repertoire
and often those who start playing at the high age.
The lessons at YMS are held in groups (maximum eight pupils per group). This
fact brings both advantages and disadvantages. The school stresses the playfulne-
ss and usefulness of the ability to play the musical instrument in pupils’ future life
(pupils are allowed to play what they fi nd interesting and they can later use their skills
and knowledge in music bands, etc.). It is believed that group education automati-
cally creates the basis of ensemble playing and that different
sounds of instruments
develop colourful hearing. Music theory is learned in the process of playing itself in
order not to discourage pupils by a lot of information. The group education brings
a healthy element of competition and higher motivation connected with the desire
to please the teacher and an attempt to make other pupils admire one. An immediate
comparison of pupils is possible and children can learn from each others’ mistakes.
On the other hand, there are several drawbacks to this which will be mentioned by
the pianist – professional, the one who has studied piano playing and who uses this
instrument with all its sound and technical possibilities.
The biggest disadvantage is the lack of work on the sound quality of a tone (the
teacher in the observation lesson said ‘we bang on the keys’)
2
, the melody of songs
is not usually played legato and children usually play with wrong fi ngering. In the
lesson
where I was present, the teacher paid attention neither to the right posture at
the piano nor to the right hand position on the keyboard. Generally, it can be said that
a close and detailed cooperation between the pupil and the teacher is missing. This
fact could be understandable due to the number of pupils in the lesson. The number of
pupils plays the role in lesson effi ciency. Children usually play the piece together so
it is diffi cult to distinguish individual differences and mistakes in interpretation. The
low effi ciency is also the result of parents’ attitude. Most of the parents do not have
music experience (this assumption is supported by the fact that they do not want to
give their children piano education) and so they cannot help their children with home
preparation. The parents presented in the lesson did not really show any interest in
their
children activity, they did not make any notes.
In a group education, it is not easy to devote individual attention to every pupil
and it is not possible to enable each student to study at their own pace. Thus, more
talented children do not have the adequate advance and the pace is too slow for
them.
Teaching materials contain several attractive, catchy and simple tunes, mostly
English and American. What I fi nd surprising and shocking is the statement in the
2
An observation lesson in October 2009 at elementary school Jasanová in Brno – Jundrov led by Petr
Dvorník.
72
M
AGDA
V
ELIČKOVÁ
introduction of the book ‘Fun Key Kids’. It says that both instruments,
the piano
and the electronic keyboard, are musically equal! While one of the main differences
which can be seen at fi rst sight (regardless the work on the tone and keystroke) is the
size of the keyboard which is only fi ve octaves on electronic keyboards.
According to the professor Alena Vlasáková, the promotion of YMS which repre-
sents electronic keyboards as more convenient (in comparison to pianos) is false.
Parents who do not understand the problem deeply value only the fact that electronic
keyboards need not be tuned, are cheaper and occupy less space. At the same time,
they are not told that the tone is created in a different way on the classical type of
piano and that this has a signifi cant infl uence on developing important preconditions
in brain cortex which are vital for the child development.
3
In comparison
with the above-mentioned, the piano education at elementary
schools is done at a much higher level, it is more precise and requires a continuous
preparation. At least, with pupils who are preparing for conservatory entrance exams
or with these who want to play music of different genres and styles correctly and
these who want to have enough technical skills for that.
An individual piano lesson requires a great concentration and systematic work.
The main features are individual attitude and interpretation with the focus on the
quality of the tone, right fi ngering and hand position and technical abilities. Natural
is playing by heart.
It is either impossible to compare the outcomes of each alumni. While elementary
music schools follow the curriculum which every student must keep to (according
to their abilities), at YMS, due
to the absence entrance exams, children of different
abilities are in the same group. The group is after some time re-structured on the basis
of children abilities. Each group has its own pace, so it is not possible to state the
outcomes after a certain number of lessons or at the end of the school year / grade.
Pupils learn from different music textbooks which may take different time to master
so it is possible to describe outcomes only after fi nishing each textbook.
Dostları ilə paylaş: